Guide A · Review a plan
Review your GTM leader's plan
Your VP, CRO or CMO has built the annual GTM plan, and you need to decide whether to back it. These ten questions, with the weak and strong answers to listen for, show which numbers have evidence behind them, even if you've never run go-to-market yourself.
How to run the review
You don't need to know the right answer to each question. You need to know what a strong answer looks like, and the table below shows you.
- Send the questions a week ahead. Ask for the working behind each number, because a summary slide isn't enough.
- Ask your leader to score the module questions for your stage from 1 to 4, alone. Score them yourself too, then start with the biggest gaps between you.
- Take one module per conversation, so each gets enough time.
- Agree what changes, and who owns each change, before you sign the plan off.
Ten questions
The questions follow the five modules in order. Each one shows the live module questions it draws on. Each question is tagged with the stages where it applies. The page shows the questions for the stage you've chosen in the toolkit bar.
1. Which segment and motion deliver most of the number? What have you stopped to pay for it?All stages
Weak answer"Mid-market and enterprise, with self-serve alongside." Nothing is on the stop list.
Strong answerOne core segment and one lead motion, with the customers who fit it. At A and B, retention cohorts for that segment support the capacity going behind it. A stop list names what gets no new capacity.
2. Which two or three assumptions does the plan rest on? What result would show one is wrong, and by when?All stages
Weak answer"We've been conservative throughout."
Strong answerThree named assumptions, each with a leading indicator, a test and a date. At least one can be tested before the end of Q1.
3. Which alternative do we lose to most, in the buyer's words? What does the plan change because of it?All stages
Weak answer"We lose on price." Or nobody records why deals are lost.
Strong answerA win-loss log in buyers' words, with the top loss tied to a change in the plan. At A, new sales hires win against it about as often as the founders did. At B, the answer holds in each segment and country.
4. Which channel does the plan count on for most new customers? How much of that rests on results we've already seen?All stages
Weak answer"We're scaling paid, outbound and partners in parallel."
Strong answerOne or two channels, with the cost of each new customer. At Seed that cost counts founder time. Every experiment has an owner, a budget and a scale-or-stop result agreed before it started.
5. Walk me from the target back to the pipeline we need, by quarter and channel. Which conversion rates come from founder-led deals?Series A, B
Weak answer"Coverage looks healthy." One ratio covers the whole year.
Strong answerA quarterly build by channel, using last year's conversion rates and cycle lengths. Deals closed without a founder are shown separately, and the biggest stretch on last year is named.
6. Which numbers in this plan can we produce from our systems today? Would finance get the same figures?All stages
Weak answer"We'll pull it together for the board pack."
Strong answerPipeline, ARR and churn each have one definition, agreed with finance. Every new customer traces back to the channel that found them. The plan lists any decision that rests on data we can't produce yet, with a date to fix it.
7. How much of the number depends on people not yet hired, or on a founder still closing? What happens if either runs a quarter late?All stages
Weak answer"Recruiting is on track."
Strong answerAt Seed, the founders' weekly selling time, and a scope for the first hire saying what must be proven first. At A and B, a capacity model with ramp times from past hires, and the target re-run with each hire a quarter late.
8. Which decisions move from the founders to you, and which stay? Are you here to build the playbook or run one?All stages
Weak answer"We'll work it out as we go."
Strong answerA one-page split of GTM decisions that the founders and the leader both agree, with a date for each one still to move. The hiring plan and timeline match a build or a run remit. At B, the next managers are named.
9. Does the pay plan reward what the strategy needs? Do the quotas add up to more than the target, and by how much?All stages
Weak answer"Same plan as last year." It pays for new logos while the growth depends on expansion.
Strong answerEach role is paid for the outcome its part of the strategy needs, such as new logos, expansion or a new segment. At Seed, the first hire's pay follows what they must prove. At A and B, quota cover over the target is stated for each team.
10. Who owns the plan once it's approved? When do we next review it, and what would make us re-plan?All stages
Weak answer"We'll revisit it at the half-year."
Strong answerA review calendar with an owner for each meeting, and re-plan triggers written down. At Seed, the team has agreed how a failed experiment gets called.
For the benchmarks behind a strong answer at your stage, such as growth, CAC payback and retention, see each module's Good looks like row.
Questions for the marketing plan
Add these when a CMO or VP Marketing has built the plan, or when marketing owns a large share of the pipeline target.
| The question | A strong answer shows | Stage | From |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. What share of the pipeline target does marketing own, by segment and channel? Can sales work that volume? | Marketing's share built from last year's conversion by source, and checked against sales capacity in module 05. | Series A, B | m03-q3, m05-q6 |
| 2. Which positioning or messaging changes are planned? What in the win and loss reviews supports each one? | Each change traced to loss reasons in buyers' words. | All stages | m02-q1, m02-q3 |
| 3. What does a new customer cost from each channel? Which channel would you cut first? | Cost and payback by channel, with the first cut named. At Seed, each test has its scale-or-stop result set in advance. | All stages | NEW-03a, NEW-03d, m03-q24 |
| 4. Can we trace each new customer to the channel that found them? Does sales accept the same answer? | A source recorded on every new customer, in one view that sales and marketing both use. | All stages | NEW-04b |
| 5. How is spend split between buyers in market now and those who'll buy later? How is each part judged? | Two budgets with their own measures. Pipeline judges the first. Reach and recall among buyers in the category judge the second. | Series A, B | m02-q2 |
| 6. When buyers ask AI assistants about our category, how do the answers describe us? What has changed because of it? | A dated record of answers from ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Google, with the fixes made. Guide F covers the method. | All stages | NEW-02c |
| 7. How do marketing and sales agree what counts as a qualified lead or account? Who settles it when they disagree? | Written definitions, agreed with sales and finance, and one named person who signs off changes. | Series A, B | m03-q5, m03-q14, m04-q4 |
| 8. Which early behaviours predict that a customer will stay? Does onboarding content push new customers towards them? | The behaviours named with the evidence for each, and onboarding built around them. | All stages | NEW-02a |
| 9. What will marketing stop or scale back? What does that free up for new work? | A stop list with the budget and time each cut releases. | All stages | m01-q11, m01-q14 |
| 10. Which signal will show by the end of Q1 that marketing is on track? | One leading indicator for each main channel, with the level that counts as off track. | All stages | m01-q10 |
Question 5 rests on the 95:5 rule, from research by LinkedIn's B2B Institute with Professor John Dawes of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute. It holds that only about 5% of B2B buyers are in market at any one time. In Marketing Week, Peter Weinberg and Jon Lombardo argue that "the brand that gets remembered is the brand that gets bought". A plan that judges all marketing on this quarter's pipeline will tend to starve the spend that reaches next year's buyers.
Pressure-test it in your plan
Set aside an evening with the plan and the module questions for your stage. A 3 means the answer is written down and the leadership team would give it in the same words. A 4 means it rests on data you trust, and someone checks it against results.
| Module question | What to check | Evidence for a 3 or 4 |
|---|---|---|
| How the target was built (m01-q9, all stages) | The target build beside the fundraising plan | A build from segments, channels and capacity, with any gap to the round named |
| Channel experiments (NEW-03a, Seed and Series A) | The list of live experiments | Each has a hypothesis, an owner, a budget and a scale-or-stop result agreed before it started |
| Pipeline by quarter (m03-q3, Series A and B) | The funnel build beside last year's actuals | Leads, opportunities and deals per quarter, by channel, built from your own conversion rates |
| Handover from the founders (m03-q10, Series A) | Win rates on deals closed without a founder | Sales hires' win rates shown apart from the founders', with the deal types that still need a founder |
| Forecast accuracy (m03-q19, Series B) | Forecast against result at weeks 2, 6 and 10 | Four quarters of history, with the reason for the largest misses |
| One set of definitions (m04-q4, Series A and B) | The metric dictionary | Signed off by finance, with a named owner for any change |
| Capacity and ramp (m05-q6 and m05-q8, Series A and B) | The hiring plan beside the capacity model | Ramp and quota attainment taken from past hires, and quotas that cover the target |
| Who owns which decision (NEW-05a at Seed, NEW-05d at Series A) | The split of GTM decisions | Written down and agreed by founders and leader, with dates for decisions still to move |
What differs by stage
| Stage | What the plan should be | Probe hardest | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seed, typically under $1M ARR | A set of funded channel experiments, with the founders still selling | Questions 1, 4 and 7. Whether the founders agree the ICP and stop list, and how much selling they keep | A first GTM hire before any channel repeats |
| Series A, typically $1M to $5M ARR | One motion becoming a playbook other people can run | Questions 5, 7 and 8. Win rates without a founder, the capacity model, and which decisions move to the leader | Headcount doubled on founder-led win rates |
| Series B, typically $5M to $20M ARR | Several motions, channels or countries, run through managers | Questions 1, 4 and 9 for each motion and region, plus forecast accuracy and the next managers | Capacity going to a new country or product before the core segment is proven |
The leader the plan needs also changes by stage. Guide B's section for the CEO sets out which leader suits each one.
Red flags
Any of these in the plan is a reason to ask for the working behind it.
| Red flag | Ask for | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| The target was set before the capacity model was built. | The capacity model, and the target it supports by itself | Series A, B |
| Conversion rates are better than last year's, with no reason given. | Last year's actuals beside the plan, and the change behind each improvement | Series A, B |
| Every segment is a priority, and nothing is on the stop list. | The segments that get no new capacity this year | All stages |
| Channel experiments have no agreed result that means stop. | A scale-or-stop result for each, set before the next one starts | Seed, Series A |
| New sales hires are planned at the founders' win rates. | Win rates on deals closed without a founder | Series A |
| The plan depends on hires that have no start dates. | Hire dates, ramp times, and the target with each hire a quarter late | All stages |
| A number in the plan only makes sense with the leader there to explain it. | Where it comes from in the CRM, and finance's version of it | All stages |
| Pay rewards new logos while the growth depends on expansion. | Each role's pay plan beside the part of the target it delivers | Series A, B |
| Every win is put down to the process, and every loss to the market. | The last ten losses in the buyer's words, and what changed | All stages |
| This quarter's commit carries deals that were in last quarter's commit. | The slipped deals, with the reason for each | Series B |
| Deals in commit carry no named risks, across the whole team. One such deal is worth probing. A whole team doing it makes the forecast suspect. | How often a deal with no named risk slipped last year | Series B |
| There's no record of what the forecast said at week 6 of past quarters. | Forecast against result at weeks 2, 6 and 10 | Series B |
Then take it to the board
Once you and your leader have agreed the changes, run Guide B, Prepare your plan for the board as an exec team. This review tests whether the plan holds together. Guide B tests whether you can show it, with an exhibit behind each answer.
- Start with what the board needs to leave with, so the plan you've agreed ends in clear asks.
- Several questions here come back as board questions. The strong answers you collected become exhibits in the pack.
- If the review left you unsure whether your leader suits the next stage, read For the CEO before the meeting. Boards often raise it in a closed session.
Sources
Want a second view
on next year's plan?
More red than you expected? We can help fix it, working inside the business with your team. We'll reply within one working day.
Let's talkInvesting in a company that needs this? See how we work with VC and PE funds.