Guide F · Positioning

Position your product

Positioning is the context that helps the right buyers see why your product is the better choice for them. April Dunford's method, which Ascent uses, gives you the working parts. Al Ries and Jack Trout show why a position must be short enough to stick in a buyer's mind. Geoffrey Moore makes the case for winning one segment first.

Where this sits in your plan

Module 02 asks for a positioning statement and an alternatives table. Module 01 tests two of the four fits between market, product, channel and model that depend on it. Does the story work in the channels you use? Does the market understand the difference and value it? Guide G covers the fits in full.

Ascent pairs positioning with jobs to be done (Guide G). The job a customer hires you for shows which alternatives they weigh you against.

Is positioning the problem?

In two pieces for Lenny's Newsletter (2021 and 2024), April Dunford lists signs that the problem is positioning before product:

  • Buyers ask you to pitch it again, or say they could do the same thing in a spreadsheet.
  • Sales, marketing and the founders each describe the product differently.
  • Deals only make sense to the buyer after an extra sales call.
  • The competitors on your slides never show up in real deals.
  • Deals end with no decision. In her 2021 guide, Dunford gives a typical figure of a quarter of deals lost that way.

Module 02's questions test for the same signs. If two or more are true, the positioning question in module 02 can't honestly score above 2.

Three ways to look at positioning

All three treat positioning as a choice about who you're for, from different starting points.

SourceWhere it startsWhat it asks of your plan
Ries and Trout, Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind (1981)Buyers keep a short mental list for each category. You win by owning one clear idea on it.One short claim, said the same way everywhere
Dunford, Obviously Awesome (2019)What customers would do if your product didn't existAn alternatives table with proof for each difference
Moore, Crossing the ChasmWin one segment, then use it to reach the nextA named first segment, and a rule for moving on

Ries and Trout first set out the idea in Advertising Age in 1972, as Al Ries recounts. Their book sums it up as "what you do to the mind of the prospect".

Dunford's five components, in order

Dunford works through five components in a set order, each building on the one before. Her quickstart guide (2021) describes them, and Obviously Awesome (2019) sets out the full method.

ComponentThe question it answersWhere it lives in the toolkit
Competitive alternativesWhat would customers do if your product didn't exist? This includes doing nothing, a spreadsheet or hiring someone.The alternatives table in module 02
Differentiated capabilitiesWhat can you do that the alternatives can't?The positioning statement in module 02
ValueWhat does that make possible for the customer, and how would you prove it?Value statements in module 02's messaging
Best-fit customersWho cares most about that value, and what do they have in common?The ICP one-pager in module 01
Market categoryWhat frame makes that value obvious to those customers?The positioning statement in module 02

Dunford treats market trends as an optional layer on top, useful when a trend makes the value more urgent. Build the alternatives from real deals, because a list written from memory tends to name the competitors you watch.

Win one segment first

Dunford's best-fit customers and Moore's beachhead segment are the same decision. On Lenny's Podcast (2024), Moore says to judge a segment on its size, whether you can lead it and how well it fits your strengths. He wants one "big enough to matter, small enough to lead", where buyers have a compelling reason to buy. Their success stories then help you sell to the next segment. At Series B, treat each new segment, product or country as a new beachhead, with its own alternatives table.

Should you create a new category?

Creating a new category is expensive, because the market has to be taught what it is. The authors of Play Bigger (2016) argue that category leaders take about three-quarters of the profits and market value. Dunford's evidence suggests most companies do better in an existing market. In her 2021 guide she notes that 90% of tech companies that went public in the previous five years were positioned in existing markets, and that category creators often lose in the long run.

The usual move for a startup is to win a smaller part of an existing category.

  • Janna Systems, where Dunford worked, couldn't win enterprise CRM but could win CRM for investment banks. Revenue grew from under $2M to close to $80M, and Siebel bought the company for $1.3B (Dunford, 2021).
  • Paperless.io moved out of the crowded eSignature category into document automation, positioned as 'more efficient than DIY, less complex than DocuSign'.
  • Userlist changed its homepage from email automation for SaaS to customer messaging for SaaS, without changing the product (Userlist, 2022).

A narrower focus can change how a company ends up. Adelphic, where Nick was GM EMEA, refocused from a product serving many parts of the ad-tech and mar-tech ecosystem into a high-growth demand-side platform, a rival to The Trade Desk, and was acquired by Time Inc. Your plan should say which part of the market you will lead and what you will stop chasing.

Say it in one line

Once the five components are settled, Geoffrey Moore's positioning statement from Crossing the Chasm sums them up.

For [target customer] who [need], [product] is a [category] that [benefit]. Unlike [alternative], our product [differentiation].

Keep it internal, and say the same thing in buyers' words on your site. Then apply the Ries and Trout test. Could a buyer repeat it to a colleague after one hearing?

Turn it into a pitch

In Sales Pitch (2023), Dunford builds the sales pitch from the positioning, with a short setup and a longer follow-through, as she explains on Lenny's Podcast. Summaries of the book list eight steps.

  1. Insight into what's changed in the market
  2. The alternatives buyers use today, with the pros and cons of each
  3. Agreement on what a great solution would do
  4. An introduction to who you are
  5. Two or three value themes, each shown in the product
  6. Proof that the value is real
  7. Objections, answered before they're raised
  8. The ask

This structure comes from summaries of the book. Check it against Sales Pitch before you train a team on it.

Positioning for AI answers

Many buyers now meet your positioning in a summary written by someone else's model. Forrester found that in 2025, 30% of buyers rated generative AI tools as a meaningful interaction in the final commit stage of a purchase, against 17% for product experts. In a G2 survey in March 2026 of 1,076 software buyers (G2 sells visibility services, so it has an interest), 51% said they now start research with an AI chatbot more often than with Google. In 6sense's 2025 buyer research, 94% of buying groups had ranked their preferred vendors before first contact, and the vendor buyers preferred before talking to sellers won 80% of deals.

An answer engine squeezes you into a sentence or two, much like the mental list Ries and Trout describe.

  • Use the same words for category, best-fit customer and differentiation on your site, review profiles and listings. Answer engines draw on all of them.
  • Write pages that answer buyers' questions in their words. Module 03 covers answer engine optimisation as a channel.
  • Ask ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Google what your buyers would ask. Keep a dated record of the answers and what you changed.

This guidance follows Forrester (January 2026) and G2 (April 2026). Neither offers a tested method yet.

Pressure-test the positioning in your plan

Set aside an evening with your statement, your alternatives table and notes from recent won and lost deals. The last column shows what earns a 3 or 4.

Module 02 questionWhat to checkEvidence for a 3 or 4
One-sentence description (m02-q1)How recent customers describe you in reviews and callsTheir words match your category and main difference
Alternatives, answered the same way (m02-q2)Ask two sellers to answer each rowOne agreed answer per alternative, with proof
Loss reasons in the buyer's words (m02-q3)Sort recent losses by what the buyer did insteadThe top loss maps to a row, and the plan changes because of it
AI answers (NEW-02c)The four tools' answers to your buyers' questionsA dated record, with fixes where answers were wrong
New sales hires' story (m02-q5, Series A)Your newest hires' recorded callsThey win against the main alternative about as often as founders did
Across segments (m02-q6, Series B)Each segment's loss reasons against its tablePositioning answers each segment's losses, with a named owner

What differs by stage

StageWhat we'd expect the plan to say
Seed, typically under $1M ARRAn alternatives table built from what buyers say on founder sales calls, and one first segment you can lead
Series A, typically $1M to $5M ARRPositioning the first sales hires can deliver without a founder in the room, and a review before moving into a new segment
Series B, typically $5M to $20M ARRThe same category, best-fit customer and differentiation in every team's story and listing, with a table and an owner for each priority segment

Revisit positioning when you move into a new segment (a module 01 question at Series A), when the alternatives buyers compare you with change, and at the quarterly re-plan in module 05's operating rhythm in between. Dunford argues that the shift to AI is forcing widespread repositioning, because buyers no longer have a stable set of alternatives.

Sources and credits

Want a second view
on next year's plan?

More red than you expected? We can help fix it, working inside the business with your team. We'll reply within one working day.

Let's talk

Investing in a company that needs this? See how we work with VC and PE funds.