Series A · From experience
When the story stops matching the buyer
A far larger opportunity, a different buyer, and one brand trying to speak to both.
Module 02 of 5 · Product marketing · What the plan decides
Prospects like the product, then struggle to explain why it matters.
How buyers find and judge you changed in 2026. Here's what that means for next year's plan.
Buyers now meet your positioning in an AI answer first, and those answers change who they buy from.
Name your category and your best-fit customer in plain words, the same way everywhere you're described, so an AI summary gets you right.
One story from Nick's career: where this part of the plan broke, the early sign, and what fixed it.
Series A · From experience
A far larger opportunity, a different buyer, and one brand trying to speak to both.
What breaks · Module 02 · Series A
Prolific grew fast after YC and a Series A, serving researchers, academics and product teams. Then a far larger opportunity opened: data and tools for frontier labs and applied AI companies to train and evaluate models. Shared platform, different category, buyers and jobs to be done. Our brand, positioning, value proposition and website began saying different things to different people.
Two at once. Core users told us they felt they no longer mattered. And new buyers landing on the site converted below benchmark.
We rebuilt positioning and messaging from customer research, for both segments. Content written for each ICP fuelled a multi-channel campaign engine, and the website gained two front doors, one for each segment.
Clayton Christensen asked "What job is the customer 'hiring' it to do?" Land on your homepage as each of your ICPs in turn. Does each one see its job within seconds, and do your first customers still see theirs?
From Nick Buckley-Mills, founder of Ascent.
What the module asks of your plan. Score them in the assessment.
What the plan has to decide, and what you should be able to show once it has.
Seed
Series A
Series B
Go deeperD Decide how you chargeE Set your pricesF Position your product
Ask these before you sign the plan off.
Seed
Series A
Series B
What good looks like at your stage, with a published figure where there is one.
Customers describe the product in the same words the founders use, a prospect can follow it from the website without a call, and the team shares one definition of an engaged customer, backed by the behaviours that predict retention.
The first sales hires win against the main alternative about as often as the founders did, and the price holds without a discount on most deals.
Each segment has its own message map and package, discounting is consistent across regions, and the team reviews win and loss reasons every quarter and changes its pitch as a result.
None of the three benchmark sources publishes a stage figure for this module.
More red than you expected? We can help fix it, working inside the business with your team. We'll reply within one working day.
Let's talkInvesting in a company that needs this? See how we work with VC and PE funds.
Readiness score
Each question is a provocation, the kind a sharp board member would ask before backing the plan. The score is a readiness score. It shows how far the plan's answer is made, agreed, written down and backed by data you trust. A low score marks where to dig before you commit. A question your team scores differently marks an argument to have now, in the planning meeting, before it comes up in front of the board.
Score each question from 1 to 4 using these definitions. There's no middle score, so you have to pick a side. Have each leader score alone, then compare.
A module's score is the average of its questions. Look at any 1 whatever the average says, because one undecided question can undo the rest of the module. At Seed, a 3 is a strong result on most questions, since a 4 needs data that most Seed companies don't have yet. 1 shows as red and 4 as green.
Nobody needs an account. Each person's answers stay in their own browser until they choose to send their link.
Each module's design ends with a "Good looks like" line for each stage, with a published benchmark where one exists. The figures come from High Alpha's 2025 SaaS Benchmarks Report, which groups companies by ARR. As a guide, the toolkit reads under $1M ARR as Seed, $1M to $5M as Series A and $5M to $20M as Series B. Funding rounds and ARR don't line up neatly, so read each figure as a rough guide.
ICONIQ's 2026 State of GTM reports across all its respondents without a split by stage. Meritech's benchmarks cover public and late-stage companies and sit behind a login, so this version doesn't use them. None of the three publishes stage figures for win rate, pipeline coverage, quota attainment, ramp time, burn multiple or the magic number, so those questions have no benchmark here.