Guide G · PMF and beyond

Find fit beyond product and market

Product-market fit is where growth starts, and it's where many plans stop asking questions. This guide helps you decide what counts as fit, measure it in levels and test it across all four of Brian Balfour's fits, as module 01 asks.

Where this sits in your plan

Module 01's questions test fit differently at each stage. At Seed they ask what would prove fit and who decides (NEW-01a), and which event shows a customer is getting value (m01-q12). At Series A they ask who reaches that event on time (m01-q13). From Series A they ask whether retention curves flatten (NEW-01b), and at Series B which of the four fits is weakest (NEW-01c). Each stage's Design row turns the answers into one exhibit.

Why stop at product and market?

Marc Andreessen's 2007 definition describes product/market fit as being in a good market with a product that can satisfy it. Plans often treat it as done once they reach it. CB Insights found that 43% of VC-backed startups that shut down since 2023 cited poor product-market fit among their reasons, and some of them were later-stage companies.

Shreyas Doshi, who worked with Nick at Stripe when Nick led the UK and Ireland business and Shreyas was a product manager on Stripe Terminal, described fit as 'a dynamic state based on your progress towards your vision'. Brian Balfour makes a similar point, that market-product fit comes in degrees and changes over time.

Decide what counts as fit

Write the test down before you look at the results. Name the evidence, the level that counts and the person who makes the call. Otherwise fit tends to be declared after a good month.

First Round Capital's Levels of PMF replaces the yes-or-no question with four levels. Each is judged on satisfaction (how much people need the product), demand (how quickly and for how much you can sell it) and efficiency (whether it grows repeatably). Its typical ranges overlap with the toolkit's stages, Seed to Series B.

LevelTypical stageWhat it looks like
NascentPre-seed and SeedA problem worth solving for three to five customers, up to $500K ARR
DevelopingSeed and Series AFive to 25 customers, $500K to $5M ARR, and a scalable channel starting to show
StrongSeries A to C25 to 100 customers, $5M to $25M ARR, at least one scalable channel plus referrals
ExtremeSeries C and later100 or more customers, more than $25M ARR, two or more scalable channels

Sean Ellis's test is a quick check on satisfaction. If more than 40% of users would be very disappointed without the product, he would say you have fit. Superhuman raised its score from 22% to 58% by segmenting to its best users and building for them. A survey is one input. Pair it with the value event and retention below.

Find the value event

Mark Roberge (The Science of Scaling) separates product-market fit from go-to-market fit. Product-market fit means customers succeed consistently. He measures it with a leading indicator of retention, where P% of customers achieve event E within time T. He often sees P set between 60% and 80%, and T between one and three months.

Pick an event you can see in product data and that a customer would recognise as value. A login or a signed contract doesn't count. At Series A, track the share reaching it on time by segment and cohort. A share that falls in a newer segment is an early warning for where the plan puts sales capacity (m01-q14).

Go-to-market fit means you can repeat that success profitably, which he judges on unit economics. That means lifetime value above three times acquisition cost, payback under 12 months and a magic number above one. Module 03, Revenue growth systems, asks the plan to show it. He warns against hiring a sales leader before product-market fit is met.

Read the retention curve

The value event predicts retention, and the retention curve confirms it. Plot the share of each cohort still paying over time. Sequoia's data science team explains why the shape matters. A curve that flattens shows some customers found lasting value, and the higher it flattens, the healthier the product. Without fit, "the retention curve will continuously decline". Before fit, later cohorts also tend to retain worse than the earliest adopters. Watch for that when a new segment or country joins the plan.

The four fits

Growth stalls when one part of the go-to-market falls out of line with its neighbours, even where product-market fit is strong. This is why the toolkit treats the go-to-market motion as the decisive lever for a software company's outcome, ahead of its product category or funding label. Brian Balfour's Four Fits (2017) pairs market, product, channel and model. Module 01 uses his four at Series B (NEW-01c).

FitThe questionA sign it's broken
Market and productDoes this market want this product enough to keep using it?The leading indicator of retention isn't met
Product and channelCan the product reach buyers through channels you can afford and scale?Acquisition cost rises with every new channel tried
Channel and modelDo the price and contract size pay for the channel that sells it?Payback stretches as the channel scales
Model and marketAre there enough buyers at this price to reach the target?The plan needs more customers than the segment holds

Balfour notes that "Products are built to fit with channels". The fits influence each other, and when one changes you have to revisit them all. Guide D covers the model. Positioning shapes how the story travels through a channel and whether the market values the difference. Guide F covers it.

Which kind of fit do you have?

Sequoia's Arc framework (2024) describes three kinds of fit, and each calls for a different go-to-market plan.

ArchetypeWhat it meansWhat it asks of GTM
Hair on fireAn urgent problem buyers already know they have, usually in a crowded marketSpeed and a strong sales effort, with a product that is clearly different
Hard factA pain buyers have accepted as part of lifeEducation first. Show buyers the problem can be solved, helped by early evangelists
Future visionA new way of working that buyers find hard to believe inA long road, funded by commercial traction along the way

Two companies can both have product-market fit and need opposite plans. A hard-fact product sold with a hair-on-fire playbook is likely to burn through pipeline that was never ready to buy.

Define the market by the job

Clayton Christensen's jobs to be done (2016) defines the market by the job customers need done. Customers hire a product to get a job done in a particular circumstance. In the best-known example, commuters hired a morning milkshake to make a long drive more interesting, so its real competitors were bananas and bagels. Ascent uses jobs to be done alongside Dunford's method, because the job shows which alternatives a customer weighs. Guide F turns that into positioning.

The ICP one-pager in module 01 asks for the jobs each persona needs done. A good value event is the moment that job gets done.

How fit moves

Fit can slip. Markets shift, new segments behave differently from the first, and AI changes what buyers compare you with. Roberge warns that scaling itself can compromise both kinds of fit. At Series B, a competitor's move can weaken a fit within a year. Name the signal you'd see first, and who watches it.

Fit can also be rebuilt. As CRO, Nick led Prolific's pivot from a profitable, slow-growing business into a critical enabler of frontier and applied AI, growing gross revenue from $53m to more than $200m.

Pressure-test it in your plan

Set aside an evening with your fit test and cohort data. A 3 means written and agreed. A 4 means it rests on data you trust and someone checks it monthly. At Seed, a 3 is a strong result.

Module 01 questionWhat to checkEvidence for a 3 or 4
Evidence that fit is real, and who decides (NEW-01a, Seed)Ask each founder what would prove fit, and who calls itA one-page fit test with the evidence, the level that counts and a named owner. For a 4, it's checked monthly
The value event and its timing (m01-q12, Seed)Ask each founder separately for the event and the timeEvery founder names the same event and window, and it shows up in product data
Share reaching the value event on time (m01-q13, Series A)A monthly cohort table by segmentThe share for each segment and cohort, rising in the core segment, with a reason where it isn't
Retention curves (NEW-01b, Series A and B)Curves by cohort for the core segment, then for newer segmentsCurves flatten in the core segment. The plan names the cohorts that don't, and why
Capacity follows fit (m01-q14, Series A and B)Where new sales hires go, against each segment's cohort dataEach segment that gets capacity has evidence of fit. The rest get none, by agreement
The weakest of the four fits (NEW-01c, Series B)The four-fits scorecard from the Design rowA rating and evidence for each fit, the weakest named, a market signal to watch and an owner

What differs by stage

StageWhat we'd expect the plan to say about fit
SeedA written fit test with an owner, and an agreed value event. Too few cohorts to read a curve, so lean on the leading indicator
Series AThe value event tracked by segment and cohort, a flattening curve in the core segment, and sales capacity where that evidence is strongest
Series BRetention by cohort for each segment and country, and a rating for each of the four fits, with spend aimed at the weakest

Sources and credits

Want a second view
on next year's plan?

More red than you expected? We can help fix it, working inside the business with your team. We'll reply within one working day.

Let's talk

Investing in a company that needs this? See how we work with VC and PE funds.