Guide C · Sales methodology

Choose a sales methodology

A sales methodology shapes how your team runs the conversation with a buyer. A qualification framework decides whether a deal is real enough to forecast. At Seed you need neither by name, and by Series B both should be in every deal review.

Do you need one yet?

A methodology and a framework give a team one way to run deals and one language to describe them. That pays off once someone other than a founder sells. Before that, the founders are learning what buyers need, and a borrowed framework can hide that learning behind its own vocabulary. In his review of Pete Kazanjy's Founding Sales, David Skok says founders should sell "their first handful of customers before professionalizing their sales org". Stage 2 Capital, writing on Mark Roberge's The Science of Scaling, names "hiring sales teams before customer value creation is consistent" as a common and costly mistake.

It's probably too early if:

  • the founders still close almost every deal, and the ICP is still moving;
  • you can't yet say what buyers needed to see before they signed (NEW-03g).

It's time if:

  • a first sales hire is closing deals this year, or will be;
  • two people would put the same deal in different stages (m03-q5);
  • deals in commit slip, and nobody saw it coming.

What changes at Seed, Series A and Series B

StageWhat the plan should sayModule 03 questions
SeedNo branded methodology. A one-page note, built from recent deals, of what buyers needed to see before they signed, and a written walk-away rule. These become your first qualification criteria.NEW-03g, NEW-03f
Series AOne framework and one methodology, chosen as the first sales hires join. Pipeline stages defined by what the buyer has done, with the framework as exit criteria. The methodology is how new hires learn to win without a founder.m03-q5, m03-q10
Series BManagers inspect deals every week against the same stage criteria and named risks, and the forecast is tested against last year's accuracy. Each motion can have its own framework if all of them share one stage model.m03-q12, m03-q16, m03-q19

At Series A, watch for a framework copied from a much larger company, filled in to satisfy the CRM while the founders still decide which deals are real. At Series B, watch for frameworks drifting by team, so the forecast adds up deals judged in different ways. Module 05 asks how much of each manager's week goes on deal inspection (m05-q5).

How a founder and CRO choose

Answer these together, using last year's won and lost deals as evidence. That gives you a shortlist. At Series A, the founder and the first GTM leader do this before the first hires start.

QuestionPoints towards
How many people are involved in a typical purchase, and do legal or procurement get involved?More stakeholders and paperwork point to MEDDPICC. One or two buyers suit BANT or ChAMP.
What are the typical deal size and sales cycle?Small, fast deals need something light. MEDDPICC's detail pays off on large deals with long cycles.
Do buyers already know they have the problem?If they don't, a teaching approach such as Challenger or Command of the Message. If they do, discovery-led methods such as SPIN, Gap Selling or SPICED.
Can the buyer measure the value in money or time?Frameworks that make value explicit, such as MEDDPICC's Metrics or Command of the Message.
How experienced are the reps, and how much time do managers have to coach?A framework simple enough for managers to inspect in every weekly deal review.
Is there a product-led motion?Qualify on usage signals first (m03-q13 and m03-q14), and apply the framework only to deals that need a sales conversation.
What can the CRM and deal reviews capture today?One you can build into the CRM and your deal reviews today.

Then roll it out in order:

  1. Shortlist one methodology and one qualification framework.
  2. Pilot them for a quarter with one team, on live deals. At Series A that may be the whole team, so include a founder in the pilot.
  3. Build the chosen pair into CRM fields, deal reviews and the forecast call, and train managers to inspect them. Write the pipeline stages as buyer actions, with the framework as exit criteria (m03-q5).
  4. Review after two quarters and adapt it to how you sell, as Nick did by adding R for Risk.

Matching them to the motion

Reps use a methodology to run the conversation and a qualification framework to judge whether a deal is real, so most teams pair one of each.

MotionQualificationMethodology
Product-led or high-velocityBANT or ChAMP, kept lightSPIN for the deals that need a conversation
Mid-market, sales-ledChAMP or MEDDICSPIN or Solution selling
Enterprise, with procurementMEDDPICC plus RChallenger

MEDDPICC, plus R for Risk

Nick adds an R for Risk. Before a deal goes into the forecast, the rep names what could stop it or slip it: timing, a budget freeze, the champion leaving, a reorganisation, or a change in procurement. Each risk gets a mitigation and an owner.

The R forces the question. The rep, and the VP or CRO reviewing the deal, have to look hard at what could go wrong. That catches "happy ears" early.

A deal in commit with no named risk gets probed in the review. If reps across the team name no risks, treat the forecast itself as a red flag.

Module 03 asks at Series B how often a deal with no named risk slips (m03-q12). Log named risks in the CRM for two quarters and you'll know. You'll also have a better basis for weighing commits against historical conversion in the forecast call (m03-q19).

Sales methodologies

A methodology shapes how reps run the conversation, from discovery to close.

MethodologyWhat it doesBest fitSource
ChallengerTeach, tailor and take control. The pitch runs in six steps: the Warmer, the Reframe, Rational Drowning, Emotional Impact, A New Way, Your Solution.Complex sales where buyers need a new view of their own problemMatthew Dixon and Brent Adamson, The Challenger Sale (2011)
Command of the MessageValue messaging: the buyer's required capabilities, the outcomes they want, and how you deliver them differentlyTeams that need one consistent value story across reps and productsForce Management (summary)
SPINDiscovery through four kinds of question: Situation, Problem, Implication, Need-payoffLarger, considered sales where discovery decides the dealNeil Rackham, SPIN Selling (1988)
Gap SellingDiagnose the gap between the buyer's current state and the future state they want, and sell to closing itSales where the buyer's problem is real but not yet quantifiedJim Keenan, Gap Selling (2018)
Solution sellingDiagnose the buyer's problem, then fit the solution to itSales where the product is configured to each buyerMichael Bosworth, Solution Selling (1994)
SandlerA structured selling system that agrees the next step and the budget early, and qualifies hard before presentingTeams that waste time on deals that were never going to closeDavid Sandler, Sandler Training (founded 1967)

The Challenger steps come from summaries of the book. Check them against The Challenger Sale before you train a team on them.

Qualification frameworks

A qualification framework is the checklist a deal has to pass before it counts as pipeline or goes into the forecast.

FrameworkCoversBest fitSource
BANTBudget, Authority, Need, TimingA quick early check in simpler, transactional salesOriginally developed at IBM
ChAMPChallenges, Authority, Money, PrioritisationMid-sized sales where the buyer's problem matters more than processA widely used variation of BANT
SPICEDSituation, Pain, Impact, Critical Event, DecisionSaaS sales built around customer impact, including recurring revenue after the first saleWinning by Design
MEDDIC and MEDDICCMetrics, Economic buyer, Decision criteria, Decision process, Identify pain, Champion, plus Competition in MEDDICCB2B sales with several stakeholders and no heavy procurement stepDeveloped at PTC in the mid-1990s. Dick Dunkel, Jack Napoli and John McMahon are credited (Andy Whyte, MEDDICC)
MEDDPICCMEDDICC plus Paper process, with Implicate the painMid-market and enterprise sales with legal and procurement involvedMEDDICC

Pressure-test it in your plan

Work from last quarter's won and lost deals and your stage definitions. A 3 means written down and agreed by the leadership team. A 4 means backed by last year's data and tracked every month. A framework missing from the CRM and the deal review scores 2 at most.

Module 03 questionWhat to checkEvidence for a 3 or 4
What buyers needed before they signed (NEW-03g, Seed)List what each recent won deal had to see or proveThe same few proofs recur, and the founders' written process is built from them
The walk-away rule (NEW-03f, Seed)Deals the founders turned down last quarter, and whyA written rule, with named deals declined because of it
Stages defined by buyer actions (m03-q5, Series A)Ask two reps to stage the same three live dealsEach stage has exit criteria written as buyer actions, and the reps agree
First hires against the founders (m03-q10, Series A)Win rates for deals closed with and without a founderThe gap is measured, and the playbook names the deal types that still need a founder
Weekly inspection and named risks (m03-q12, Series B)Sit in on one manager's deal reviewEvery commit deal has a named risk with an owner, and you know how often deals with no named risk slipped
Where conversion drops (m03-q16, Series B)Stage-to-stage conversion by segment, source and rep cohortThe weakest stage is known, and its exit criteria changed because of it
Forecast accuracy (m03-q19, Series B)The forecast at weeks 2, 6 and 10 against the result, for each quarter last yearAccuracy is tracked every quarter, and commits are checked against historical conversion

The outputs belong in module 03's Design table. At Series B, the board guide asks a sharper one. Which of last year's wins would your own qualification rules have ruled out?

Sources

Want a second view
on next year's plan?

More red than you expected? We can help fix it, working inside the business with your team. We'll reply within one working day.

Let's talk

Investing in a company that needs this? See how we work with VC and PE funds.